Creamy Banana Cream Pie Recipe - Food.com (2024)

55

photo by DeliciousAsItLooks

1. Has anyone tried making this with real whipped cream vs Cool Whip? Curious if it would just fall flat or would work our fine. This sounds soooooo good!

   Liz W.

2. The Creamy Banana Cream Pie recipe calls of 1 6-oz. package of instant pudding - is this a 5.9 oz box of instant pudding that makes 6 one half cup servings? If so is the 1/2 cup of milk amount correct?

   kteeling

   See Also

   The Best Instapot Recipes - speeds up cooking up to SIX times!Grandma's Melting Moments Cookies RecipeHealthy 5-Ingredient Dinner Recipes to Save Time and CaloriesKeto Potato Salad Recipe - 1.8 g Net Carbs - Ketofocus

Reviews

1. I made this twice, the first time using regular cool whip and cream cheese, the second time with light. Although both tasted good, the regular made a noticeably better presentation and had a better texture. I also used a graham crust.

   djafishfria

2. Excellent! I made with diet vanilla pudding for my husband reduced sugar needs and was still delicious. The diet pudding made a little hard to mix in- had to use electric mixer.

   Melissa Kochis

3. I made this with light cream cheese, light Cool Whip and 1% milk. Those who ate it said it was my best pie yet! The crust was pretty moist when I took it out of the oven, but I resisted the urge to bake it longer since I made that mistake with a graham cracker crust and it turned out rock hard. The crust ended up being perfect, it was easy to cut through, held its shape, and was crumbly when you ate it. Yum! The recipe was the perfect size for my 10 inch pie pan.

   SashasMommy

4. I used a graham/pretzel crumb crust and banana cream pudding mix. This was the very best banana cream pie that I have ever tasted!! I doubled the recipe and used a 13x9 pan.

   55tbird

   See Also

   Crock Pot Cheesy Potato Soup Recipe - Slow Cooker Potato Soup

5. Made this little gem for a potluck, got rave reviews, what a hit. I like others was confused with the size of pudd

   BakinBaby

see 46 more reviews

Tweaks

1. I used 1 1/2 cups milk with a 5.1 oz. package of vanilla pudding and sprinkled crushed shortbread cookies on top. I also set aside 1/2 cup whipped topping and some of the banana slices to decorate the top of the pie with.

   DeliciousAsItLooks

2. I was so excited to make this that I left out a couple of important steps. For starters, I completely forgot to bake the crust. By the time I realized this, I had already poured in the filling. So, remember to bake the crust! Fortunately, the ingredients of the crust are safe and edible in their raw form (although a bit floury). The other mix up was that I used regular pudding mix instead of instant. I couldn't understand why the mixture was so loose and overflowing the pie dish. Then after reading the reviews, I learned that someone else did the same thing. It was too late for me to fix this as I had already blended in the remaining whip (I used healthier TruWhip). However, I was concerned that the pie wouldn't firm up so I stuck it in the freezer for an hour or two. Believe it or not, this saved the pie and it came out delicious. But I know it'll be even better once I include the items I missed. In summary: bake your crust and used INSTANT pudding. Can't wait to make this again!

   Anonymous

3. This is a delicious pie, and I don't even like banana cream pies! I substituted graham cracker crumbs for 1/2 the flour, and did the pecans in the food processor to make them fine. I wasn't paying close attention at the grocery store or at home and used regular instead of instant banana cream pudding mix the first time - it was soup! Went back to the store, got the right stuff and put it together - I did need an extra splash or two of milk for the pudding part. Excellent pie. The crust was fantastic.

   slrickman

4. The taste was great, even if it didn't look the way I wanted :)Things to take note of next time: (1) make sure nuts (I used walnuts instead of pecans) are really finely chopped so you have a better looking crust; (2) use 2 bananas instead of 3; (3) try using a 10" cake pan instead of a pie plate so you don't have to have crust on the sides (it came out too thick for me); (4) use 1 regular package pudding mix (a 3 oz sachet would do) because I had to put in more milk and cool whip than what was required with 6 oz.

   Shasha

5. Very good, creamy and light. A great dessert after a big meal. Great crust. Did not exactly make it to the diner table. Had some friends over and they devoured it. Next time I will try with banana instant pudding instead of vanilla. I also make one of these where I do not put bananas but use butterscotch pudding instead. Simply scrumptious.

   Terry in New Brunsw

see 1 more tweaks

Advertisem*nt

Advertisem*nt

Advertisem*nt